Originally Posted by
;
Dr Bob
The Exact Same Guy from WizeTrade and PremiereTrade? If so congratulations for making the move, George and James' loss is our gain.
There is lots of advice given out here, and you've gathered a massive amount of experience in the one year you have been trading, thank you for sharing that. You clearly have plenty of followers.
Is there anybody who has traded this method on a live account?
I'm about to properly finance my account after 6 weeks of proving I have a method in place. It is not this system here, as I have had as many unsuccessful set-ups because I did follow throughs when I looked at everything you post. It is also boring sitting there waiting for candles to shut on what seems to me more than a Line Chart. My loss possibly.
For me, anything on a 15 minute chart is too little a time frame. I trade off the Futures and Bond prices, and then confirm with the technicals on the 1 hour and 4 hour charts when trading the Yen. These cross-over lines just aren't reliable enough on something as volatile as the Yen.
I'm not looking to market my way of trade, far from it. It is ideal for me and I have developed a Plan that will not suit everybody, I don't want the pressure of something not working, and have accepted that 30 percent of my trades will fail. I've great enough money management in place to make a winning Trading Plan. Maybe after a year of me using it live, I will look to share it, but only if it remains as dependable via all kinds of Market scenarios. That's why I am curious about who has used what you market, on a Live account, and has a history of making it function.
Genuine question, I couldn't see a refference for it in your articles, but for so many trade set-ups that get posted by you I only wondered how so many people are trading it Live, and the number of have a history of success using it. Have you been live trading these set-ups Dr Bob? If so, what percent return does the'Not all of the Pips, But All The Trades' really return you annually?
Hope you don't mind me asking, but I have seen a lot of threads posted here that promise to return, but with hardly any Account Balance statements to back it up. Seems as though most have given up on the Red Line Green Line system. That was meant to be a winner but nobody revealed they may make that one work either.
I hope that I don't get slammed with people asking'how dare you raise this question'. To me if it is posted in a public domain it ought to be contested. In case you've already answered this in another thread then point me in this direction, I couldn't find anything on it.
Thank you for your time.