Is Trading FX A Noble Profession? - Page 2
Page 2 of 842 FirstFirst 12
Results 11 to 14 of 14

Thread: Is Trading FX A Noble Profession?

  1. #11
    I dont care if it's commendable or not, as long as my signal suppliers generate a fantastic profit for me I will think of it as the ideal profession.

  2. #12
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    Working as a bank teller could be respectable, but there's nothing particularly noble about it.
    You contradicted yourself. You mentioned being a bank teller isn't a occupation that was commendable. And after that you agreed with me you need to give a service to be eligible as noble.

    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    OK, now you're on to something. By your own statement you've defined trading not noble. Trading doesn't provide society a support that is required, nor does it bring about society's well-being. See what I did there? Isn't this fun. Now use your definition over and attempt to work in trading as a noble profession... will not happen.
    Read my mentioned possible jobs that could branch out from being a trader.

    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    If you really do feel the need to add to the society as a trader. You are able to consider fund for individuals, train individuals to exchange compose transaction books and so on. For doing that, You'll acquire income. There are so many possible career paths which may be obtained from being a trader.
    What is your purpose? Are you really not giving individuals the right? Are you currently despising?

  3. #13
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    You contradicted yourself. You mentioned being a bank teller isn't a noble job. And you and I agreed you want to provide a service to be eligible as noble.
    Being a bank teller isn't a noble job. Bank tellers do provide a service. Providing a service alone does not qualify as noble (nor did I say it did, as then again, any job that provides a service could then be eligible as noble). Sanitation, ne, policing, teaching-- these are without. At best you are able to assert that being a bank teller is more believable than being a trader, but it is still barely a noble profession and isn't regarded as such by nearly anybody except people in this thread trying their hardest to craft a definition of noble which could incorporate trading.


    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    Read my mentioned possible tasks that may branch out from being a trader.
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    In case you really do feel the need to contribute to the society for a trader. You are able to think about managing fund for individuals, train individuals to trade write transaction books and so forth. For doing that You'll get extra income. There are just so many possible career paths which may be obtained from being a trader.
    Fund supervisor? Noble? Cash in order to generate more money for the wealthy? Sure, it provides a service, but noble? HAH!

    Coaching traders? I barely think training individuals to perform something that's not noble is noble. That does not make any sense. If drug dealing (or any job that you want to throw in here) isn't noble, then training individuals to drug deal isn't noble, either.

    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    What's your point? Are you not giving individuals the right to trade? Are you curious individuals who trade?
    I think I have made my point very clear, a lot of times. I'm not against investing, otherwise why would I'm actively trading and here. I have said nothing of the sort about the right of individuals to trade, nor have I mentioned anything about despising.

    I am only telling you that by any normal definition of noble, trading isn't a noble job, and that this does not mean it is bad (I have literally said this three or more times within this thread now), as very few tasks are actually noble.

    Your difficulty is that you are conflating commendable with noble. I understand we all want to think what we do (or want to do) is a noble career path, but it is just simply not when you actually understand what noble way, or compare it to people really doing noble work (again I would point to MSF as the ideal example).

  4. #14
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    Being a bank teller isn't a commendable occupation. Bank tellers do supply a service. Providing a service does not qualify as noble (nor did I say it did, as then again, any occupation which supplies a service could then be eligible as noble). Sanitation, ne, policing, teaching-- these are without. At best you can assert that being a bank teller is much more noble than being a trader, but it's still barely a noble profession and isn't regarded as such by pretty much anybody except folks in this thread trying their...
    Reality check # 1

    Read first post

    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    I'd like some folks views on it I think it is due to the risk management and plogical aspects of it and shows bravery.
    View is defined as an individual and personal understanding, decision, or interpretation; an impression.

    The discussion scope is on people's OPINIONS. OP at least know the idea whether Forex is noble or not differs from people to people.

    Reality check # 2

    Just how many people agree that Foreign Exchange isn't noble so far in this thread?

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
This website uses cookies
We use cookies to store session information to facilitate remembering your login information, to allow you to save website preferences, to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners.