Does anybody suggest any Volume Spread Analysis Indiors? - Page 2
Page 2 of 845 FirstFirst 1234 ... LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 41

Thread: Does anybody suggest any Volume Spread Analysis Indiors?

  1. #11
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    How do VSA be applied to Currency Market, anyhow? Doesn't VSA, by it's definition, analyze volume? Without a centralized exchange to track volume, what potential significance can we get from broker-provided quantity information?
    I don't use this, but I have seen a lot of folks using it and they're quite good traders. So, yes it's possible.

    And there is a reason behind everything, it is possible to always know the why. Always.

  2. #12
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    I do not use this, but I have seen a lot of people using it and they're extremely great traders. So, yes it's possible.

    And there's a reason behind everything, it is possible to always understand the why. Always.
    They may use Volume out of Futures Market (which is not real volume) but certainly not some bad butt bucketshop MT4 volume. It's utterly useless you could aswell just plot some arbitrary numbers.

  3. #13
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    They can use Volume from Futures Market (which isn't real quantity) but surely not some bad butt bucketshop MT4 volume. It is utterly useless you could aswell just plot some random numbers.
    I have seen one quantity system on here which utilized quantity from currency futures.
    I will try to find it and edit this post to identify it.

    So far as I know, quantity figures given out by futures exchanges are accurate, however there is a lot I really don't know.

  4. #14
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    I have seen one quantity system on here that utilized quantity out of currency futures.
    I will attempt to loe it and edit this article to spot it.

    So far as I am aware, quantity amounts given out by futures exchanges are accurate, but there's a lot I don't know.
    Of course they are more accurate than that which you will see on your MT4, since no 500M Dollar Hedge Fund transactions in IBFX or even Alpari. Institutional Traders trade amouts through CME for example. Still there's alot of quantity which is not
    counted since it does not go through CME. If Airbus wants to hedge a 1 Bln USD bargain with another nation or whenever you run to your bank and swap
    your cash for a holiday trip overseas or in case your government needs to buy dollars from china which raises the demand for dollars etc etc ). This is Volume which is not possible to keep track of.

  5. #15
    I would venture to state that nobody here has read Willi' novel. If they had, they'd already know that tick volume is what VSA utilizes in FOREX. Netdania has it free. FXCM says theirs is from liquidity suppliers, e siignal has it for about $40 per month. MB volume is from ECNS ticks. There are lots of resources and it is precisely what is utilized. This sort of argument just shows that the book has not yet been read and understood.

    Read the publiion. It is quite a price driven method and is very trustworthy.

  6. #16
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    I would venture to state that nobody has read Willi' novel. When they had, they would already know that tick quantity is exactly what VSA utilizes in FOREX.
    It still misses ALOT of important quantity. PERIOD.
    And with ALOT I really mean ALOT.

  7. #17
    Nonsense. Read the book. That is from page 27

    esignal quantity is what their program uses.
    https://www.forexforum.co.za/attachm...3223318257.pdf

  8. #18
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    The U.S. budget deficit is financed by borrowing. More and more of the cash comes from China, now the United States' second-largest creditor, after Japan. China's investment in U.S. government debt has more than tripled in the past five decades, from $71 billion in 2000 to $242 billion in 2005.
    Lol show me the way your imaginative Tick Volume repesents buying of a quarter trillion dollars.
    In recent years it was near 900 Billion. Oh well I guess we can ignore peanuts.

  9. #19
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    Lol show me the way your ingenious Tick Volume repesents buying of a quarter trillion dollars.
    You obviously don't understand this method, so there's no use discussing it with you until you read the book.

    I have read your posts and know you're a good trader, but you're not getting the point of the system.

    I think if you read the content, you may change your mind as your argument has no validity in this circumstance.

  10. #20
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    I'd venture to say that nobody has read Willi' novel. If they had, they would already understand that tick volume is what VSA utilizes in FOREX.
    Yes, we know that. But your not fixing our issue. The tick volume in forex that's supplied by your broker is not universal, it is specific to your broker. So just how can you know when a 100 billion dollar fund is investing in your currency as soon as your tick volume will not reflect their trade?

    The included page does not address Forex. It addresses that tick volume may be used but does not handle the issue inherent to forex volume... which it is not comprehensive. In stocks yes, tick volume can be used since you can poll the exchange. That is not true in forex.

    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    You clearly don't understand this technique, so there is no use discussing it with you till you read the book.
    You're shutting down conversation with a patronizing remark like this? Come on. I have read novels on VSA, frankly... not one of the techniques I understand about would work on Forex due to the volume issue over. I am more than prepared to admit I am wrong if you can prove differently, but so far you haven't even addressed the situation.

    That brings up the question, should they utilize esignal volume... where does esignal volume access it's info from? There's no universal exchange for spot forex, so there's no volume authority we can ask.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
This website uses cookies
We use cookies to store session information to facilitate remembering your login information, to allow you to save website preferences, to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners.